LTE: KC area public school districts remain concerned about aspects of Mayor James’ sales tax proposal to fund early childhood education

Dr. Gayden Carruth
Special to Northeast News

Improving and expanding early childhood education is vitally important to Cooperating School Districts of Greater Kansas City. Our 32 member districts strongly support increased services for our youngest learners and appreciate being able to review the pre-kindergarten tax plan created by the Kansas City mayor’s office.

In addition, our organization is thankful for the opportunity to work with the petitioners and Mayor Sly James to seek better understanding and reasonable compromise. Although the mayor’s office has collaborated on some issues, we remain concerned about several unresolved items. For the sake of our more than 177,000 students, we believe our districts should have been involved with the mayor’s team in the plan’s original design.

All our districts provide pre-kindergarten programs and share a commitment to young children. With this commitment in mind, we are sharing our three main concerns — governance, constitutionality and revenue — while also providing solutions.

Governance. The current plan essentially removes locally elected boards of education from any significant governance role. All but two of our 14 districts involved in the proposal educate students from multiple municipalities other than Kansas City. Locally elected school boards are charged by state statute with making “rules and regulations for the organization, grading and government in the school district.” These statutes do not assign responsibilities for the districts’ governance to a tax board or other entity — as would be the case in the mayor’s plan.

Constitutionality. The current tax proposal would provide funding for private sectarian and parochial schools in direct conflict with Missouri Constitution Article IX, which specifically restricts public funding for any “institution of learning controlled by any religious creed, church or sectarian denomination.”

Revenue. In addition to the issue of public funding being diverted to private schools via vouchers, we are concerned about the actual amount of revenue going to students as well as the method of taxation. According to the mayor’s plan, only 25 to 30 percent of the approximately $30 million in sales-tax revenue will be spent for direct services to children during the first three years. Our districts also agree with other organizations expressing concerns about the regressive nature of a sales tax, which disproportionately impacts those least able to pay.

These issues not only face the district’s superintendents attending the meetings with the mayor and the petitioners, they are vitally important to the families of the 32 districts represented by our organization. Our districts have worked diligently toward a reasonable compromise but do not believe the current plan is right for our districts and, more importantly, our children.

Our recommendation to Mayor James is that all parties come together to support individual local school districts’ property-tax initiatives, if the districts choose this method of revenue. In addition, we support the mayor and our school districts collaborating to pursue a state-wide funding method for expansion of early-childhood education.

Targeted property-tax initiatives and state funding would allow the citizens of each district to prioritize their OWN needs and address these with community-based plans for expansion of early learning programs, along with other educational opportunities for students. In terms of a state-wide solution, we are already working to help draft a bill within the General Assembly to provide early-childhood funding through the Missouri Foundation Formula. Each of the 14 school districts within Kansas City’s city limits have agreed that these options are the best and most equitable methods for expanding pre-kindergarten education for ALL.

Our students are our top priority. At the same time, we must protect the role of our local boards of education to nurture and support their students and to represent the desires of citizens living within multiple communities. It is inaccurate and unfortunate to characterize our lack of support for this plan as a lack of concern for children. Nothing could be further from the truth. We seek fair and effective solutions for ALL students.

Dr. Gayden Carruth is executive director of Cooperating School Districts of Greater Kansas City.

Comments are closed.

  • Infrastructure in Eastern Jackson County should be a priority

    June 5th, 2019

    Dear Editor,   I recently had to drive to Independence on several days during the recent rains.  I drove through […]

    LTE: Clean up Gladstone Boulevard!

    May 1st, 2019

      My partner and I were doing a little trash pick up today in celebration of Earth Day and we […]

    LTE: The mayoral election is about Troy Schulte

    April 24th, 2019

    The upcoming mayoral election will likely leave Historic Northeast without a voice. Neither Quinton Lucas nor Jolie Justus has shown […]

    LTE: Bike plan lacks community input

    February 27th, 2019

    To the dismay of many in Scarritt Renaissance neighborhood, the KCMO Bike KC plans for Historic Northeast, specifically Gladstone Boulevard, […]

    LTE: Questions about bike lanes

    February 27th, 2019

    Why is our local government so eager to paint brand new bike lanes over our pot-holed streets?  Is it so […]

  • LTE: Elections have consequences

    January 2nd, 2019

    Missouri’s 100th General Assembly will convene Jan. 9, 2019 at 12:00 p.m. Members will be sworn in and special guests […]

    LTE: Every Problem Is An Opportunity In Disguise

    December 19th, 2018

    “Every problem is an opportunity in disguise.” When I was growing up, my father had this John Adams quote prominently […]

    LTE: Who would you rather help?

    November 14th, 2018

    Recently, a Northeast family with a young child and an infant on the way was hit with a series of […]

    LTE: Farm Bill would impact SNAP benefits

    November 14th, 2018

    Every five years, our federal legislators take on the task of renewing the Farm Bill, a hundreds-of-billions-of-dollars piece of law […]

    Reflecting on my time at the Northeast News

    October 10th, 2018

    Paul Thompson Northeast News A decade covering news in Kansas City will leave a wealth of memories. Many of you […]

  • What’s Happening

    Lykins Neighborhood on stellar trajectory

    Over 40 professional architects, designers, and community developers spent Thursday morning touring and assessing the Lykins neighborhood.

    TIPS Hotline reward increased in effort to reduce crime in Kansas City

    Top local and federal law enforcement officials announced an increase in TIPS Hotline reward money from $10,000 to $25,000.

    Folk band Short Round Stringband performing at Summer Dusk Concert tonight

    Tonight's Summer Dusk Concert, featuring Short Round Stringband, will be at 7 p.m. tonight at The Colonnade in Kessler Park.