Letter To The Editor: Truman wouldn’t tear down monuments

President Harry Truman once said that a page of history is worth a volume of logic. As both a student and a maker of history, I am sure he would decry the demands that Confederate monuments be removed from public places. I am also sure that he would be outraged by the vandalism of several such monuments since the recent riot at Charlottesville, Virginia.

Removing or destroying statues and the like is equivalent to tearing pages out of a history book. It is intolerance. It is censorship. One of the more outlandish protests was directed at the stone bench erected in south Kansas City in 1934 by the United Daughters of the Confederacy  (reported August 23 in the Northeast News). This was no towering statue of a Confederate general but a mere park bench. What irked the agitators was that this piece of furniture was dedicated to the memory of the women of the Confederate states. Are we supposed to forget that myriads of Missouri men – including some of Mr. Truman’s forebears – fought under the stars and bars with the support of their mothers and wives?  Now that the bench (Kansas City’s only public Confederate monument) has been removed, it is just a little more likely that they will indeed be forgotten.

Disapproval of a historical figure is not grounds for banning statues or books. It is as silly as demanding that a paper quit printing news about people someone doesn’t like. Further, if we were to mandate a seal of approval for every person memorialized, hundreds of statues would have to be toppled. Consider the one of Andrew Jackson in front of the downtown courthouse. It was the brainchild of Harry Truman, who wanted a historically accurate likeness of Old Hickory to go with what was then the new courthouse. Jackson is shown astride a horse and wearing a military uniform. This is Jackson as he appeared when he fought the Battle of New Orleans. Jackson went on to become president and to do many good things for his country. Yet he has his critics. He was a slaveholder. He fought duels. And he was responsible for the mass removal of native Americans from the South to what is now Oklahoma. Thousands of them died on the way there. Their journey was called the Trail of Tears.

Mr. Truman knew all of this, but he wanted the people to remember the man for whom their county was named. Hence the statue — and an important page of history.

Dennis Stack

Historic Northeast

Comments are closed.

  • LTE: American Jazz Museum needs leadership change

    April 25th, 2018
    by

    I’ve spent this term on the City Council as the Chair of our Finance & Governance Committee many times having […]


    LTE: Teens need history lesson on gun rights

    April 4th, 2018
    by

    I would like to respond to the three letters printed in the March 28 edition en mas. First, in the […]


    LTE: Student walkouts have been inspirational

    March 28th, 2018
    by

    In Bunny the News Hound’s recent editorial (Mar 21), she has not given us “The Bigger Picture,” but a much […]


    LTE: Unfair assumptions of youth

    March 28th, 2018
    by

    The Bunny piece (from March 21) re: gun control was a one sided piece. I understand the purpose of Editorials, […]


    LTE: Scalia’s majority opinion

    March 28th, 2018
    by

    Judging from Bunny’s last commentary in the 3/21 edition, it appears that the wheels have finally fallen off our beloved […]


  • LTE: Beads, Beans, & BOOZE will be bigger, better than ever

    February 7th, 2018
    by

    This year the Northeast Kansas City Chamber of Commerce is excited to expand its yearly Mardi Gras Celebration: Beans, Beads, […]


    LTE: Engaged residents have an impact

    January 31st, 2018
    by

    Thank you for the recognition you gave the Scarritt Renaissance Neighborhood Association’s Block Watch in Bunny’s column last week. You […]


    LTE: McCaskill, Blunt Break From Partisan Pack For Missourians’ Benefit

    January 24th, 2018
    by

    Amid all the political noise coming out of Washington, something quite unusual happened in the Senate last year that Missourians need to know. […]


  • What’s Happening

    Garfield Elementary students help beautify Pendleton Heights’ Orchid Alley

    By Paul Thompson Northeast News In an otherwise nondescript alley in the Historic Northeast’s Pendleton Heights neighborhood, Garfield Elementary students […]

    Downtown Kansas City’s dominant skyline

    Michael Bushnell Northeast News This week’s postcard was published by the R.B. Harness Greeting Card Company of Kansas City, Mo. […]

    retorts illustrated by bryan stalder

  • Local Weather

  • Free tax preparation for most taxpayers!