KCMO street condition discussion sets off fierce debate

Paul Thompson
Northeast News

What was billed as a simple accounting maneuver related to Kansas City’s road conditions became much more during a joint committee meeting at City Hall on Thursday, May 3.

Regardless of the intent of Resolution No. 180302 – which initially proposed lowering the City’s threshold for triggering depreciation of its 6,500 lane miles of roads from a condition level value of 60 (out of an 100 point scale) to 40 – the end result was a protracted discussion about the state of Kansas City’s roads, and a condemnation of City priorities that have seen the road system slip into poor condition.

That discussion ended with the majority of the Finance & Governance and Transportation & Infrastructure joint committee voting to advance substitute language that expresses the City’s intent to “retain a condition level at an overall value of not less than “60” for its roadway system,” while also reaffirming the City’s commitment to implementing a comprehensive approach to street improvement, maintenance, and resurfacing.

The scale for road conditions suggests that a rating from 90 to 100 would reflect excellent condition; 80 to 89 would represent good condition; 70 to 79 would represent fair condition; and anything below 70 is considered poor condition. Road conditions are calculated in three-year cycles; the fiscal year that concluded in April 2018 would mark the third consecutive year that KCMO streets were graded below 60, if they reach the City’s own estimation of 48 out of 100.

When the road conditions from the 2017-2018 fiscal year are finalized, KCMO Finance Director Randy Landes suggested, the City will be forced to act, one way or another.

“You’re at the trigger right now,” Landes said. “Either you have to change the trigger, or you have to depreciate your assets.”

According to 1st District Councilman Scott Wagner – the joint committee’s lone vote of dissent – the committee substitute advanced on Thursday, May 3 would ultimately trigger a series of actions that includes the depreciation of KCMO streets if it is passed by the full Council on May 10.

“By keeping it at 60, since we’re going into our third year of what we expect to be below, then that will cause a series of requirements to kick in which include depreciating and having to begin to track what the preservation work that we do in the future will do in adjusting that value,” Wagner said. “Instead of spending more money on road work and maintenance, we’re now going to have to spend more money on staff.”

Fourth District Councilwoman Katheryn Shields, though, suggested that the extra work Wagner alluded to is what the City should have been doing all along: back when it initially lowered the trigger number from 80 to 60, and then again now.

“We not only didn’t depreciate, but when we set it at 60, we didn’t even maintain it at 60. Now they’re coming back and saying to do it at 40,” Shields said. “When you establish that lower number, you have to account for that loss of value. I don’t believe the City did that.”

To Shields, the issue is simple: the roads in Kansas City have been degrading over the years, and thus should be depreciating. The accounting measure proposed by the original resolution, then, should be considered a distortion of the true value of Kansas City’s road system. Essentially, Shields believes that reducing the threshold to 40% is akin to ignoring a problem that isn’t going away.

“We wouldn’t have gone from our roads being estimated at being at 80% condition to now being 48% if we’d been connecting these dots sooner, and actually investing the money in our roads,” Shields said. “But we as a Council – certainly the members of this committee are saying – no, we’re not just going to brush away the problem we have with not maintaining our roads by just adopting a new standard.”

What to Shields is a line in the sand about infrastructure spending is to Wagner a conflation of related but distinct issues. Wagner maintains concerns that the committee substitute could eventually lead to motorists driving on Kansas City streets that essentially have no value; a potential reality he called “crazy.”

“This is an accounting resolution,” Wagner said. “That’s all it was; that’s all this still is, because there is not an appropriation attached to this.”

That said, the issues raised by Shields swayed the joint committee on May 3. Next, the full Council’s legislative session on May 10 will make a final determination on an accounting measure that has become a lightning rod at City Hall.

Comments are closed.

  • Homeless man charged in 2017 murder

    11 hours ago
    by

    A homeless man pleaded guilty Monday to 2nd Degree Murder and Armed Criminal Action in the November 2017 stabbing of Roderick Browning-Torrence.


    Riverfront Homeless Camps in Harms Way

    March 21st, 2019
    by

    For the section of Kansas City’s homeless population that live along the banks of the river, the rising river levels spell trouble in a big way.


    Residents can now visit Canady’s campaign office to sign the Paseo Petition

    March 20th, 2019
    by

    Residents who are interested in signing the Paseo Petition can stop by the campaign office of Alissia Canady for Mayor


    St. Joseph’s Day preparations

    March 20th, 2019
    by

    Elizabeth Orosco Northeast News Thousands of cookies, pastries, various dishes, and fruits were prepped for this year’s Saint Joseph’s Day […]


    City Council candidates address pressing community issues

    March 20th, 2019
    by

    Elizabeth Orosco Northeast News Ten candidates vying for 3rd and 4th District City Council seats attended the Northeast forum Saturday, […]


  • Fourth District Candidate Guide

    March 20th, 2019
    by

    Six candidates are running on the April 2nd ballot for the 4th District City Council seats. At-Large candidates include current […]


    Save the Paseo Petitioners officially hit the streets

    March 20th, 2019
    by

    Northeast News Following the contentious legislative session of Kansas City’s City Council January 26, 2019, that saw the passage of […]


    Northeast residents make further clean up efforts in Kessler Park

    March 20th, 2019
    by

    Johanna Pounds Editorial Assistant Northeast News On Friday, March 15, many Northeast residents gathered to do another trash clean up […]


    Kansas City Police searching for suspect in Family Dollar robbery

    March 19th, 2019
    by

    Kansas City Police are trying to identify this man who robbed the Family Dollar last month.


    KCPD respond to shooting in Northeast Kansas City

    March 19th, 2019
    by

    Kansas City Police Officers responded to a shooting Tuesday, March 19, around 7 am in Northeast Kansas City.


  • What’s Happening

    CID: Around The World In 80 Minutes

    The Old Watts Mill

    Michael Bushnell Northeast News You might visit the area around 103rd Street and State Line Road if you were interested […]

    retorts illustrated by bryan stalder