Homemade Girl Scout Cookies

Dorri Partain
Northeast News

America’s largest cookie sale began with one Girl Scout troop in 1917. The “Mistletoe” troop of Muskegee, Oklahoma had a successful cookie sale as a service project, and the idea quickly spread to other troops across the country.

The Girl Scouts of America started in Savannah, Georgia with a fledgling group of 18 girls, lead by founder Juliette Low in 1912. The trefoil symbol was chosen to represent this new group and their 3-fold promise as recited in the Girl Scout Law.

In 1922, the official magazine for the scouts, American Girl, published a cookie recipe as an economical way for troops to raise funds. The simple sugar cookie’s ingredients could be purchased for less than 36 cents, while producing 67 dozen cookies. In turn, each dozen could be sold for 25-30 cents. The cookies were packed and sealed in wax paper bags and sold door-to-door, sometimes with a card that read:

COOKIES large and cookies small, made by SCOUTS both short and tall. What’s your ORDER? Phone us quick, So that we may do the trick. THIRTY CENTS is all we ask, And we find it is no task, to DELIVER to your door, DOZENS- one, two, three- or more!

Telephone #

Troops may or may not have used a trefoil cookie cutter, which was available for 15 cents.

Commercial bakeries first produced ready-baked cookies for the Greater Philadelphia Council of Girl Scouts in 1934. The ever-popular Thin Mint cookie was introduced in 1951 and has remained a staple offered year after year.

In keeping with the times, sugar-free and gluten-free varieties have been added to yearly offerings and the scouts have changed how they market the cookies. Replacing door-to-door sales, scouts now learn how to set up cookie booths at local businesses and how to sell cookies online. A new app, Digital Cookie, allows users to find and order cookies on their smart phone. Looking for cookies? Go to www.gsksmo.org to find a local cookie booth.


1922 Girl Scout cookie recipe
Makes 4 dozen

1 cup of butter, softened
1 cup sugar
2 eggs, well beaten
2 tablespoons milk
1 teaspoon vanilla
2 1/2 cups all-purpose flour
2 teaspoons baking powder
Sugar for decorating

Preheat oven to 375 degrees.

In a large bowl, cream butter and sugar until light and fluffy.
Add eggs, then milk, vanilla, four and baking powder, stirring well after each addition.
Shape dough into a ball, then wrap and refrigerate for 2 hours.
Roll out chilled dough on a lightly floured surface. Cut out cookies with trefoil cutter.
Sprinkle sugar on top, if desired. Place on an ungreased cookie sheet and bake 8 to 10 minutes, or until edges begin to brown.

Comments are closed.

  • Remember This? Petticoat Lane

    May 15th, 2019

    Dorri Partain Northeast News Downtown shoppers, hang on to your petticoats! At the turn of the 20th Century, when ladies […]

    Sharp Building stood downtown

    May 15th, 2019

    Michael Bushnell Northeast News This week’s postcard, published by the South West News Company of Kansas City, Mo., features a Real […]

    Swope Park – a home to exotic animals

    May 8th, 2019

    Michael Bushnell Northeast News “An idea to create the largest zoological garden in the United States. There will be nothing […]

    Remember This: Casey The Elephant

    May 8th, 2019

    Dorri Partain Northeast News Who was Casey, and where was his place? Casey, an African bull elephant, arrived in Kansas […]

    Remembering stock yards’ glory days

    May 1st, 2019

    Michael Bushnell Northeast News About two years after the opening of the “new” Hannibal Bridge over the Missouri River, Kansas […]

  • Remember This? The Golden Ox

    May 1st, 2019

    Dorri Partain Northeast News Whether you like your steak well done or medium rare, this Cowtown could offer a fine […]

    Remember This? Junior Flight Wings

    April 24th, 2019

    Dorri Partain Northeast News What do you want to be when you grow up? For young travelers flying the friendly […]

    The Golden Age of air travel

    April 24th, 2019

    Michael Bushnell Northeast News “Providing the very finest in airline service between major cities from coast to coast, this newest […]

    Remember This? Eggs Deviled

    April 17th, 2019

    Dorri Partain Northeast News Which came first- the deviled egg or the deviled egg plate? The versatile egg has been […]

    The wild waters of pre-levee Kansas City

    April 17th, 2019

    Michael Bushnell Northeast News Published by the North American Postcard Company of Kansas City, Mo., this week’s card is a […]

  • What’s Happening


    New data takes deep-dive into state of KCPS and charter schools to improve educational ecosystem for all students

    Elizabeth Orosco Northeast News Kansas City Public School District presented an analysis of the entire educational system in Kansas City, […]

    Park land for sale aims to spur neighborhood collaboration

    Elizabeth Orosco Northeast News Kansas City Board of Parks and Recreation Commissioners has voted to put 55 acres of park […]