Clean Missouri ethics reform to remain on general election ballot

Paul Thompson
Northeast News

The Clean Missouri ethics reform ballot initiative earned a courtroom victory last week when a three-judge panel of the Western District of Missouri Court of Appeals ruled that the measure should remain on the November 6 election ballot.

The decision followed weeks of speculation about the legislation, along with a short-lived Cole County judge’s ruling that the initiative needed to be removed from the ballot. The Kansas City Star’s Allison Kite reported on September 14 that Judge Daniel Green ruled that the “proposed amendment violated a provision in the Missouri Constitution that limits the scope of initiative petitions.” At issue, according to Green, was that the initiative petition would alter more than one article of the Missouri constitution, while tackling more than one subject.

Clean Missouri organizers, however, disagree.

“This is well within the bounds of single-subject guidelines,” said Clean Missouri campaign director Sean Soendker Nicholson. “The single subject is the State Legislature.”

The judges from the Western District of Missouri Court of Appeals – Judge Thomas H. Newton, Judge Anthony Rex Gabbert, and presiding Judge Alok Ahuja – found that Secretary of State John Ashcroft was correct to certify the initiative petition for the November 2018 general election ballot.

“The Secretary of State correctly declared that the Initiative Petition was sufficient, and correctly directed that the Petition appear on the November 2018 general election ballot,” wrote Ahuja. “The judgment of the circuit court is reversed.”

The initiative petition, dubbed Amendment One, garnered roughly 340,000 signatures from Missouri voters throughout the state.

Amendment One aims to dull the effectiveness of donor and lobbying spending in Missouri politics through five major reforms: 1) banning all gifts worth more than five dollars; 2) instituting a two-year moratorium on lobbying for politicians following their final legislative session; 3) lowering campaign contribution limits to $2,500 for Senate candidates and $2,000 for House candidates, while also closing contribution loopholes; 4) requiring legislative records to be held to the same Sunshine Law transparency rules as other public entities; and 5) directing the state to hire a nonpartisan expert to draw fair legislative district maps after the next census.

The three-judge panel had issued a stay on September 18, allowing the initiative to remain on the ballot. A follow-up special hearing on Thursday, September 20 – the day before military ballots were set to be shipped out – provided both sides with the opportunity to make their case before the appeals court.

A decision was made by September 21, as presiding Judge Ahuja was well aware of the timely nature of the case. He acknowledged both the military ballot deadline on September 21 and a September 25 deadline for sending out absentee ballots.

Clean Missouri left the special hearing optimistic that the voter-backed initiative would remain on the ballot.

“I think the judge was doing his due diligence, but the law is very clear. One subject and one article of the constitution: the legislature and Article 3,” said Benjamin Singer, communications director for Amendment One. “Based on past precedent, that seems to be controlling.”

Nicholson added that the will of the people should be considered. According to him, many Missourians are fed up with the status quo.

“People are disgusted with a world where politicians take $1 million in lobbyist gifts; people are disgusted with a redistricting system where it means 90% of elections are not competitive,” Nicholson said.

The ballot initiative has become a hot-button political issue, with Democrats largely in favor of the legislation’s passage and Republicans generally standing in opposition.

Some legislators spoke to the Northeast News about the ongoing debate surrounding Amendment One and Clean Missouri.

“I think it will (pass), and I think it should,” said District 19 State Representative Ingrid Burnett. “We had a large number of people who signed that petition, because it was important to them and because we have a legislature that refuses to police itself.”

Representative DaRon McGee of South Kansas City described how the legislative districts are currently developed. First, the Governor appoints six people – three Democrats and three Republicans – to draw the district maps. If they can’t agree, the courts get involved and draw the maps instead. McGee indicated that the makeup of the Governor-appointed board essentially ensures that consensus is not met. Because the court-drawn maps need to be approved by a Republican-controlled legislature and a Republican Governor, McGee contends that the maps are not equitable.

McGee has gone on the record in support of the legislation, primarily because it includes language regarding to re-drawing of legislative district maps.

“That forces people to be attuned to the people that we represent, rather than the party,” McGee said. “I think that it makes things more equitable and fair in the way that we draw districts. Right now, I think it’s completely partisan.”

On September 20, attorney Todd Graves argued in court against Amendment One, suggesting that lots of superfluous and likely popular provisions have been tied to together to gloss over the more controversial redistricting proposal.

Ahuja followed up by querying if redistricting changes would be permissible, in Graves’ opinion, if it appeared alone on the ballot, without the other provisions.
“If it was done alone, it would,” Graves replied.

Afterwards, Graves decried the initiative as a Trojan horse of sorts: popular ethics reform measures wrapped around new redistricting rules that will fundamentally alter the balance of power in Missouri. He added that there’s also a legal issue with altering campaign contribution limits that were only recently reduced by voters.

“There’s a political point and there’s a legal point,” Graves said. “The political point is that it’s a cynical attempt to draw votes to your proposal. The legal point is, the contribution limits are in one article of the constitution that was just passed by voters two years ago. They put this in another article and didn’t even mention that or amend that.”

Ultimately, the three-judge panel agreed with Clean Missouri, allowing the initiative to remain on the ballot.

On Monday, September 24, the Missouri Supreme Court officially declined to reconsider the decision of the appeals court. As such, Amendment One will remain on the November ballot.

Want Northeast News articles sent straight to your inbox each week? Subscribe below!
Enter your email address and click on the Get Instant Access button.
We respect your privacy

Comments are closed.

  • Kansas City’s Most Wanted

    June 29th, 2022

    KC Crime Stoppers has partnered with The Northeast News to help track individuals in Northeast KC on the Kansas City’s […]

    Vacant Scarritt School slated for reuse

    June 29th, 2022

    Abby Hoover Managing Editor The Scarritt Elementary School at 3509 Anderson Ave., closed in 2010 during the “right sizing” of […]

    Welcoming KC hosts International Food Tour to celebrate cultures on Independence Ave.

    June 29th, 2022

    EllieAna Hale Editorial Assistant Welcoming KC hosted this year’s KC International Food Tour in Historic Northeast, a day of celebration […]

    State Representative earns Missouri Horace Mann award

    June 29th, 2022

    Michael Bushnell Publisher State Representative Ingrid Burnett (D-19) was awarded the 2022 Horace Mann Award Thursday evening at a reception […]

    American Art Deco: Designing for the People, 1918-1939

    June 29th, 2022

    Sponsored content The Kansas City Museum’s collections of historical materials are an important means of advancing the Museum’s mission and […]

    Community partnerships at the heart of Mattie Rhodes, NEAT Mission

    June 29th, 2022

    Sponsored content Once again the Mattie Rhodes Center’s Northeast facility at 148 N. Topping is sponsoring a series of community […]

    Man sentenced to 28 years for double homicide in 2019

    June 28th, 2022

    By EllieAna Hale Jackson County Prosecutor Jean Peters Baker announced June 27 that 25-year-old Mario Markworth was sentenced to 28 […]

    Pedestrian suffers critical injuries in early morning hit and run

    June 23rd, 2022

    Update: The female pedestrian has succumbed to her injuries according to KCPD. A female pedestrian who was standing in the […]

  • Cafe Cá Phê hosts fundraising yard sale

    June 22nd, 2022

    EllieAna Hale Editorial Assistant Cafe Cá Phê hosted a Yard Sale Pop-Up Event on June 17 to fundraise and support […]

    World Refugee Day celebration brings together the stories of a diverse community

    June 22nd, 2022

    EllieAna HaleEditorial Assistant On June 18, the North-East Branch of the Kansas City Public Library hosted the city’s annual World […]

    Community Calendar

    June 22nd, 2022

    FRIDAY, JUNE 24 –Welcoming KC Presents the International Food Tour. $30 per person. CLICK HERE MORE MORE DETAILS SATURDAY, JUNE […]

    Sewing Labs welcome international textile recycler

    June 22nd, 2022

    Abby Hoover Managing Editor The Sewing Labs of Kansas City, a nonprofit teaching the legacy of sewing for employment, entrepreneurship, […]

    Students make change in Northeast

    June 22nd, 2022

    Abby Hoover Managing Editor Students from the Ryogoku Soccer Academy are creating change in their community, one project at a […]

    Troost gets creative with business collective

    June 22nd, 2022

    Aniaya Reed Editorial Assistant The Troost Market Collective (TMC) is a non-profit organization whose mission is to create equitable economic […]

    Remember this? 86-year-old Music Hall, Little Theater

    June 20th, 2022

    Eighty-six years ago, on June 14, 1936, the Kansas City Music Hall and Little Theater venue space opened inside Kansas […]

    Arts Asylum presents “Heathers: The Musical”

    June 17th, 2022

    On June 15, Faust Theatre is bringing the dark comedy, “Heathers: The Musical,” to the Arts Asylum through June 25.  […]

    Police report late death near 8th and Benton

    June 16th, 2022

    On May 28, at 5:30 a.m., officers were called to the 3200 block of East 8th Street on a reported […]

    Bushnell talks truck-eating bridge on trucker podcast

    June 15th, 2022

    The OOIDA (Owner-Operator Independent Driver Association), the international trade association representing the interests of independent owner-operators and professional drivers on […]

    Project ElderCool takes on the summer heat with a sustainable solution to heat-related deaths

    June 15th, 2022

    EllieAna Hale Editorial Assistant Summer is here and with that comes excruciating heat and air conditioning systems on blast. But […]


    June 15th, 2022


  • Northeast Newscast

  • Faces Of Northeast

  • Remember This?

  • Want articles sent directly to your inbox each week? Subscribe below!
    We respect your privacy and will not distribute your information.